On the night Donald Trump was elected, I wrote:
“No one knows what will happen to this country after January 21st, 2017. We may get 100% single-payer health care. We may get a blistering fistfight between the White House and the Republican Congressional leadership. We may get a nuclear war.
I don’t know. You don’t know. Donald J Trump doesn’t know. Because he’s not a fascist. He’s not a conservative. He’s a narcissist. He’ll do whatever he thinks benefits him in the short term. Me, you, Donald–no one know what he’ll do.
I am fucking terrified.”
Now, on the last full day of the Trump administration, I can look back and say: Yup, it was pretty damn bad. Started bad and got worse.
The ridiculous bits, like the futile trade spats, or the “Space Force.” Then the sucking up to Putin. The lackadaisical approach to the greatest natural disaster in American history. The sinister unidentified federal agents. The desperate follies of the past two months, culminating in the invasion of the Capitol.
We didn’t get a nuclear war. That’s something. Awfully low bar, though.
Given all this, can we say there was any good that came of the Trump administration?
Author Adrienne Martini saw Trump’s victory in 2016 and decided she had to do something. She got involved. Now she sits on the county board of representatives. (And she wrote a book about it.)
I joke when I say that Donald Trump was God’s way of teaching Americans how their government works, but it’s true that the average civics knowledge has slowly risen over the last four years. How the Electoral College works. What the executive branch can and can’t do. The limits of how political appointments interact with congressional approval. The ins and outs of impeachment. We have a better appreciation of political power, of how real it is. With that, a reawakening of the potential, the threat, of mass political violence.
Democracy is miraculous. Throughout human history, society has generally consisted of an elite living off practically everyone else, and enforcing that power through force. Through the labor of centuries, we have managed to create the expectation that the powerful will obey, and that violence should have no place in politics. This is a thing both marvelous and bizarre. We should cherish, and practice it. It is us, and it cannot survive without us.
There’s no such thing as free will and humans are not beings, but processes. It’s tough to be a pundit when your most basic belief is that nobody can know what’s going to happen. But in that flux, we should remember that the course of society goes as easily in a good direction as a bad one. It has. All the things we like about history are as true as all the horrible ones.
Goodbye, Donald J. Trump. Hope we don’t see you again.